Consulta OnLine (periodico online)
ISSN 1971-9892
2017/II
maggio – agosto
ANNIVERSARI
P.C.
Alle origini del Canada
contemporaneo
(01.07.2017)
Abstract
At the origins of
contemporary Canada
The paper recalls the events and ideas that characterized
the enactment of the British North America Act of 1867
P.C.
(15.08.2017)
Abstract
The twentieth star
The paper recalls the approval of the
Constitution of Missouri of 1867, highlighting in particular
the criticality for slavery
PARTE I
STUDI
ROBERTO PERRONE
(24.07.17)
Abstract
After
citing some previous decisions and underlining the principles of religion
freedom and people security, the author offers an analysis of the decision of
the Supreme Court of Cassation related to the criminal responsability
of a person belonging to the Sikh religion, because he carried a knife (called
Kirpan) with him.
STEFANO AGOSTA
Il legislatore ed il nodo di Gordio
della prevenzione vaccinale
(13.07.17)
Abstract
The paper addresses the issue of vaccination
coverage through an analysis of the solutions offered by the Government with the
decree law no. 73/2017 containing urgent provisions on vaccine prevention.
After a review of the main regulatory contents, the author deals with some
methodological issues - particularly related to the choice of this legislative
tool - such as the resort to decree law (instead of ordinary legislative
procedure), or its compliance with articles 32, paragraph 2, and 77 of the
Constitution.
ANTONIO RUGGERI
(12.07.17)
Abstract
The present contribution analyses fundamental
rights of migrants and immigrants. First, the Author defines the concept of
fundamental rights, offering an analysis that deals with theory and case law on
that issue. Second, these rights are considered in the light of the Italian
constitutional system and of the structure of the Italian Constitution. Third,
the present works considers the position of immigrants and their relationship
with the territory. In conclusion, the Author highlights the need to reconsider
thoroughly the relationship between fundamental rights, equality and solidarity
principles, on the one hand, and the duty to be loyal to the Republic, on the
other hand.
ROBERTO DI MARIA
(29.06.17)
Abstract
In
occasione di due pronunce della Corte costituzionale (i.e. 133 e 140 del 2017)
– entrambe omogeneamente riconducibili al tema “finanziario”, in quanto aventi
ad oggetto le leggi di stabilità del 2016 dello Stato e della Regione siciliana
– si è ritenuto di argomentare intorno all’opinabile definizione del thema decidendum nonché intorno
alla – altrettanto opinabile – coerenza fra gli elementi dedotti (e valutati)
dal suddetto thema. Ciò perché in entrambi i casi
pare emergere una sostanziale irrazionalità del sindacato, determinata o da una
incongrua sussunzione del raccordo ermeneutico fra oggetto e parametro, nel
primo, o dalla apoditticità della motivazione, nel secondo, in apparente
controtendenza rispetto alla logica “sistematica” che dovrebbe invece connotare
lo scrutinio di costituzionalità. Premessa la consapevolezza della
“flessibilità” di alcune norme di rito, l’impressione che si ricava è di due
decisioni infatti contraddistinte da un orizzonte analitico alquanto limitato,
in ragione o delle scelte processuali fatte dalle parti o di una delimitazione
delle questioni tale da non indurre la Corte ad una valutazione ampia ed, appunto, “di sistema” dei temi sottesi alle medesime. In
tal senso, la capacità di muoversi fra le maglie del processo costituzionale
sembra essere assurta al ruolo di “arte”: la abilità non soltanto di fare la
domanda giusta ma, soprattutto, di porgerla in termini corretti; ovverosia in
modo tale da consentire – ad un Giudice naturalmente capace di pronunce di ampio
respiro – di sussumere, dalla singola fattispecie, una regola di portata
generale e di natura “ordinamentale” (R.D.M.).
GIACOMO MANNOCCI
(29.06.17)
Abstract
After analysing the evolution of the notion of self-defence
and the regional legislative interventions in the field of legal aid, the
contribution deals with decision no. 81 of 2017, whereby the Constitutional
Court declared the illegitimacy of the rule of the Veneto Region which provided
for free legal aid for resident citizens accused of excessive self-defence.
ROBERTO CONTI
L’esecuzione delle sentenze della
Corte edu nei processi non penali dopo Corte cost. n. 123 del 2017
(29.06.17)
Abstract
The essay examines the effects of the ECtHR’s
judgments on domestic judgments (not in criminal matters) that do not comply
with the supranational court’s rulings. Starting from decision no. 49 of 2015,
in which the Constitutional Court deemed necessary a judicial remedy capable of
removing the effects of domestic judgments breaching the ECHR, the author
critically examines the new consequences of the most recent decision of the
Constitutional Court no. 123 of 2017.
GABRIELLA LUCCIOLI
Questioni eticamente sensibili:
quali diritti e quali giudici. La maternità
surrogata
(01.06.17)
Abstract
The present contribution analyses surrogate motherhood
from a legislative, jurisprudential and social perspective, taking into
consideration not only the Italian scenario, but also the comparative framework
and the case law of the European Court of Human Rights.
MARCELLO DI FRANCESCO TORREGROSSA
(01.06.17)
Abstract
The virtual community and the real community no longer
constitute parallel and independent worlds. Today, both produce daily
relationships between the various members, capable to generate potential
conflicts of interest in the selection procedures. However, according to the
Administrative Court of Sardegna, in the sentence 3rd
may 2017, n. 281, Facebook represents a simple means
of communication, not a new virtual square within which the members, who
interact with each other, can form links, damaging the impartiality of the
public administration.
ANTONIO RUGGERI
(29.05.17)
Abstract
The author, starting from a decision of the
Court of Cassation on the issue of kirpan for Sikh Indians, questions the
maximization of the protection of constitutionally protected assets (in this
case religious freedom and security) and the absence of a conciliatory solution
among the fundamental values at stake, finally identifying a way that can reconcile
the conflicting constitutional values.
GAIA VANNONI
L’interesse del minore ad
un’educazione conforme ai valori fondativi della Costituzione
(08.05.17)
Abstract
The minor's
interest in education conforms to the founding values of the Constitution
The object of the
investigation is the analysis of different cases debated by the Juvenile Court
in Reggio Calabria referring to orders of limitation of parental responsibility
in ‘ndrangheta families. The judges interpreted the principle
of the best interests of the child and the rules of the Civil Code according to
the articles 2, 30 and 31 of the Italian Constitution (G.V.).
ANTONIO RUGGERI
Per un nuovo Statuto della Regione
siciliana
(02.05.17)
Abstract
This paper presents some theoretical and
methodological questions preliminary to the contribution, offered by some Sicilian
constitutionalists, in the elaboration of a new Statute of the same Region, not
only from a discursive and conceptual point of view, but through the
preparation of a draft text (together with theoretical reflections supporting
it) which could be a reference in the elaboration of a new Statute.
ALESSIO RAUTI
La Corte
costituzionale ed il legislatore. Il caso emblematico del controllo sulle leggi
elettorali
(02.05.17)
Abstract
The relationship between legislation and
jurisdiction, especially between the legislator and the Constitutional Court,
is observed through the particular case of electoral
matters, especially with reference to judgments no. 1 of 2014 and no. 35 of
2017 of the Constitutional Court dealing with constitutional review of
electoral legislation.
Consulta OnLine (periodico online) ISSN 1971-9892